Subscribe Apps Podcasts Unstringing the Violinist Judith Jarvis Thompson's "Violinist" argument is one of the most compelling ever offered in favor of abortion on demand, but it's deeply flawed.
Overview[ edit ] In ancient times, abortion, along with infanticidewas considered in the context of family planninggender selection, population control, and the property rights of the patriarch.
Then, as now, these discussions often concerned the nature of man, the existence of a soul, when life begins, and the beginning of human personhood.
While the practice of infanticide as a form of family planning has largely been eradicated in developed countries, birth control and abortion are still practiced; and their morality and legality continues to be debated.
While modern debates about abortion retain some of the language of these older debates, the terminology has often acquired new meanings. Discussion of the putative personhood of the fetus may be complicated by the current legal status of children. Like children or minors in the U. Ireland, although this treatment was amended by the Abortion Act of in England, Scotland and Wales.
For example, the labels "pro-choice" and "pro-life" imply endorsement of widely held values such as liberty or the right to lifewhile suggesting that the opposition must be "anti-choice" or "anti-life" alternatively "pro-coercion" or "pro-death".
However, these terms do not always reflect a political view or fall along a binary; in one Public Religion Research Institute poll, seven in ten Americans described themselves as "pro-choice" while almost two-thirds described themselves as "pro-life".
Such appeals can generate confusion if the type of rights is not specified whether civilnaturalor otherwise or if it is simply assumed that the right appealed to takes precedence over all other competing rights an example of begging the question.
The appropriate terms with which to designate the human organism prior to birth are also debated. The medical terms " embryo " and " fetus " are seen by some pro-life advocates as dehumanizing  while everyday terms such as "baby" are viewed as sentimental by some pro-choice advocates.
The use of the term "baby" to describe the unborn human organism is seen by some scholars as part of an effort to assign the organism agency.
This assignation of agency functions to further the construction of fetal personhood. In politics, rights are the protections and privileges legally granted to citizens by the government. In a democracy, certain rights are considered to be inalienableand thus not subject to grant or withdrawal by government.
Regarding abortion lawthe political debate usually surrounds a right to privacyand when or how a government may regulate abortion[ citation needed ]. There is abundant debate regarding the extent of abortion regulation.
Some pro-choice advocates argue that it should be illegal for governments to regulate abortion any more than other medical practices. In general the right to privacy can be found to rest on the provisions of habeas corpuswhich first found official expression under Henry II in 11th century England, but has precedent in Anglo-Saxon law.
This provision guarantees the right to freedom from arbitrary government interference, as well as due process of law. This conception of the right to privacy is operant in all countries which have adopted English common law through Acts of Reception.
In the next few lines I´ll summarize, in the first place, J. Thomsom´s Essay; A defense of Abortion, her thesis, arguments, and some of her examples. I will then argue why Thomsom´s thesis seems to me deeper and stronger than the other three essays that we have read in class on abortion. Although I almost entirely agree with Thomsom´s argument, in my conclusion, I will try to argue that an benjaminpohle.com Publisher of academic books and electronic media publishing for general interest and in a wide variety of fields. See what you know about Judith Jarvis Thompson's ''Defense of Abortion'' with these interactive study tools. Feel free to answer these questions at benjaminpohle.com
The Law of the United States rests on English common law by this means. Time has stated that the issue of bodily privacy is "the core" of the abortion debate. The landmark decision Roe v Wade relied on the 14th Amendment, which guarantees that federal rights shall be applied equally to all persons born in the United States.
The 14th Amendment has given rise to the doctrine of Substantive due processwhich is said to guarantee various privacy rights, including the right to bodily integrity.An analytic examination of the flawed, and the important, arguments on both sides of the abortion debate.
On Judith Jarvis Thomson's "A defence of abortion" Dagmar Wilhelm This is a specially written essay by Dagmar Wilhelm who lectures in philosophy at Keele benjaminpohle.com A Defense of Abortion has 10 ratings and 1 review.
Carina said: Really enjoyed the arguments presented defining the right to have an abortion. She used e benjaminpohle.com In the next few lines I´ll summarize, in the first place, J.
Thomsom´s Essay; A defense of Abortion, her thesis, arguments, and some of her examples. I will then argue why Thomsom´s thesis seems to me deeper and stronger than the other three essays that we have read in class on abortion. Although I almost entirely agree with Thomsom´s argument, in my conclusion, I will try to argue that an benjaminpohle.com · A DEFENSE OF ABORTION I JUDITH JARVIS THOMSON Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of benjaminpohle.com://benjaminpohle.com Title: A Defense of Abortion Created Date: Zbenjaminpohle.com